hobart logo
Strange Souvenirs photo

We were sitting on a stoop somewhere in the East Village when I implied we should get married. Even a decade later that much is still clear to me. Your mother used to say the song “Suite Judy Blue Eyes” reminded her of us. Memory keeps strange souvenirs. I still don’t know whether you even heard me when I said it, because you were in the middle of being angry. You were always so quick to it. Talented at it, even. Emotional as a little boy, angsty as a teenager and then at twenty, sitting beside me with your bitten-down fingernails on your fat fingers, wrapped around the black frame glasses you very much needed and had just broken. You were always so caught up in your anger.

Even when you were angry, there was something disarmingly boyish about your face. It gave away too much. Maybe it was your full cheeks. Every sentiment arrived there several seconds before it reached your mouth. Your dark, shiny hair grew faster than you could manage and was forever falling into your eyes, which were brown and earnest behind your glasses, giving you the enduring appearance of someone confessing a secret. You often cried when you were angry. This confused people. Women often trusted you immediately, and men tended to underestimate you. Your mother got sick when you were four. And even though she lived; even though she is still alive now, mailing you birthday cards and calling too early on weekends; I thought some small part of you perpetually crouched beside that fear. I thought that small part of you remained four years old anyway, waiting. Waiting for bad news. Waiting for somebody you loved to disappear. Waiting for catastrophe, which to you seemed essentially a scheduled certainty. You expected bad things with such commitment that eventually you began helping them happen.

You were brilliant, which did not improve matters. Smart enough to intellectualize every feeling, you could rework a simple delayed text message into a philosophy of hurt. A misuttered sigh into an indictment. You loved me like you were bracing for impact. You were full of facts and jokes and observations sharp enough to keep most people from noticing how afraid you were all the time. I felt like I understood this about you, long before I understood much of anything about myself. Maybe women often do. Maybe this is our most banal universal error. Maybe your mother only ever heard the sweetness of those Crosby, Stills, and Nash harmonies when she looked at us, and missed the desperation beneath them. Missed that the song is really a seven-minute long warning track from a man frantically trying to rearrange the pieces of a love that has already ended, singing through the tears because he knows he is destined to lose. Fear is the lock, the lyrics promise.

“We should probably get married,” I’d said. Something bare and careless like that. I said it lightly enough and buried it in the conversation, so that maybe it sounded like nothing. But my cadence didn’t matter. You were already somewhere else by then, chewing through another nail, pulling apart the frames in your hands. trapped inside one of your private apocalypses.

Later, when you decided I had ruined your life, you made sure I had no way to argue with you.

In your story, I left suddenly, moved on too quickly. I ruined something permanent in you and then disappeared before I had to look at it. You blocked my phone number, my email, every account I had. You were oddly thorough. I suppose for you, anger was something more solid than hurt. Rage was a room you could build, and blame was a door you could lock from the inside.

The truth was altogether much less orderly. It had none of the clean architecture of your version. I became distant in a way that was undeniable, though I could never explain to you why. The sentence itself seemed impossible to say without making the monstrous thing more real. You wanted an explanation, an account of what went wrong and I could barely make sense of what had happened to me, much less give you the missing piece. You were frightened by anything you could not understand, and your fear often arrived disguised as control. The more you asked what was wrong, the angrier you got, the less capable I became of telling you. The more scared you became, the harder you tried to tug me back toward you. There are some experiences that seem to require a vocabulary you don't possess until long afterward. Some violations, once survived, become impossible to describe. I knew that if I told you, you would ask questions I didn't have answers for. I had spent so long learning the weather of your anger that I knew how quickly concern could become interrogation. So instead, I said nothing. It was simpler that way. I withdrew without explanation, which was perhaps the one thing you could never forgive. There are cruelties that come from malice and cruelties that come from exhaustion. I was capable of both then, I won't pretend otherwise.

A few months ago I saw someone who looked like you on the Q train. The real-life version of you that exists is now thirty, which remains as difficult for me to comprehend as my own age. But this man had your particular posture. He was hunched inward the same way, broad shoulders rounded toward his chest as though apologizing for occupying physical space. He had long messy hair that hung over the tops of his ears. I never saw his face. For a second, the sight of him hit me with such a force. I stared at his black boots. The black watch strap on his thick hairy wrists. My heart raced when he shifted even slightly. It was embarrassing. It was the kind of staring women are taught not to do because it occasionally gets us murdered. I’m suddenly struck with the most surreal sensation that you might have grown into the kind of stranger I would gaze moonily at. I felt this odd certainty that if the stranger turned around, it would be you. For years, I thought about all the things I would say if you ever spoke to me again. Back then, I think part of me concluded that you had been waiting for disaster long before you met me. We rarely remain the people we were in our twenties, still shedding and trying on new versions of ourselves. What is that decade if not a prolonged exercise in being confidently wrong? Time has a way of beating our edges down. I mistook patterns for permanence. I’d thought a person could be indelibly understood. When you’re young, you never imagine that knowing someone can be as impermanent as checking the weather. I had always assumed you still lived in New York. In my mind, you were affixed there permanently, wandering between neighborhoods I no longer visited, carrying groceries, missing trains, becoming older without my permission. I imagined tapping the man’s shoulder. Saying your name. What would I do if you looked at me with no recognition? What would I do if you recognized me immediately but wished you hadn't? I imagined you looking through me with politeness, or even disdain. I imagined you standing up and moving to another car. The train kept moving and so did my imagination, manufacturing numerous possibilities and humiliations that kept me glued to the spot. I watched stations pass. I watched the back of the man’s head as he stood and stepped onto the platform, disappearing into the crowd. For a moment I felt the impulse to follow. Then the doors closed, and the train began to move on. And because I never saw his face, I got to keep both possibilities. That it was you. That it wasn't.


SHARE